The Brawler64 NSO Edition by Retro Fighters and the 8BitDo 64 Bluetooth Controller both aim to bring the Nintendo 64 controller experience into the modern era. While each takes a different design approach, they offer similar functionality and are especially well-suited for platforms like the Nintendo Switch, PC, and MiSTer FPGA.
Design & Shape
- 8BitDo 64
Features a modern, rounded design similar to the 8BitDo Ultimate or Xbox controllers. It’s compact, ergonomic, and easy to hold. - Brawler64
Wider and more angular. While inspired by the N64 layout, it drops the classic trident shape in favor of a more traditional grip. It’s solid and spacious but has sharper edges that are more noticeable during extended play.
Comfort
- 8BitDo 64
Slightly more comfortable for longer play sessions thanks to its smooth curves and smaller footprint. - Brawler64
Still very comfortable but may cause mild fatigue due to sharper transitions along the grips.
Buttons & Stick
- Button Layout
Both controllers share the same button layout, closely mirroring the N64 configuration with modern enhancements. - Face Buttons & D-Pad
Excellent on both. Tactile, responsive, and comfortable for precision play. - L & R Shoulder Buttons
The 8BitDo’s shoulder buttons are more naturally placed and easier to press. Brawler64’s are larger and stiffer. - Analog Stick
- 8BitDo: Uses a Hall Effect stick that’s smooth, accurate, and resistant to drift.
- Brawler64: Uses a traditional modern stick with longer travel — accurate, but with a more retro feel.
Compatibility
Both the 8BitDo 64 Bluetooth and Brawler64 NSO Edition controllers are compatible with:
- Nintendo Switch (including NSO support)
- PC (Windows)
- MiSTer FPGA, where both work great with plug-and-play functionality via USB or Bluetooth.
Key differences:
- 8BitDo 64 supports Switch mode and D-Input, but not X-Input.
- Brawler64 NSO supports Switch, D-Input, and X-Input, offering more flexibility on PC.
- 8BitDo 64 includes rumble support and a Hall Effect stick.
- Brawler64 lacks both rumble and Hall Effect features.
- Both use USB-C for charging.
Input Modes & Setup
- 8BitDo 64
Features a physical slider on the back to switch between Switch mode and D-Input. Simple and intuitive. - Brawler64 NSO
Uses button combinations to switch between Switch, X-Input, and D-Input.
Also includes a dedicated button to toggle between Pro Controller and NSO Controller modes on the Switch.
Color Options
- 8BitDo 64
Available in full black and full white, including buttons. - Brawler64 NSO
- Transparent blue (slightly green-tinted) with N64-style button colors
- Full white, including white buttons
- Grey with N64-style button colors
Summary
Both controllers are excellent options for MiSTerFPGA, and which one is better truly comes down to personal preference. If you want a more modern feel with extra comfort and features like a Hall Effect stick and rumble, the 8BitDo 64 is a great choice. If you want broader input support and a chunkier N64-inspired grip, the Brawler64 NSO delivers.